Fire Island, NY Rent to Own Homes

Search Over 300 Listings Near Fire Island, NY

Finding rent-to-own homes in Fire Island, NY is quick and easy with RentToOwn.org. Our database of rental homes and rent-to-own houses in Fire Island, NY is regularly updated with a variety of single-family homes, condos, townhomes, and more to suit your needs. In addition to Fire Island, NY rent-to-own homes, you can expect to find other sale types, including for sale by owner (FSBO) homes, sherriff sales, REO foreclosures, and pre-foreclosures. Finding affordable Fire Island, NY rent-to-own homes has never been easier!

1 of 15 Street view of Old Country Rd Deer Park, NY 11729 Rent-To-Own home
    Old Country Rd
    Deer Park, NY 11729
    3 Beds, 1 Bath
    942 Square Feet, Year Built: 1961
    942 Square Feet
    Year Built: 1961
    Rent-To-Own
View Details
Street view of Mastic Beach, NC 28309 MLS home
    Mastic Beach, NC 28309
    6 Beds, 3 Baths
    2,080 Square Feet, Year Built: 2025
    2,080 Square Feet
    Year Built: 2025
    Rent to Own Eligible
View Details
1 of 11 Street view of Bay Shore, NY 11706 Short Sale home
    Bay Shore, NY 11706
    3 Beds, 1 Bath
    Year Built: 1922
    Year Built: 1922
    Short Sale
View Details
1 of 35 Street view of Auborn Ave Shirley, NY 11967 Short Sale home
    Auborn Ave
    Shirley, NY 11967
    4 Beds, 2 Baths
    1,456 Square Feet, Year Built: 1986
    1,456 Square Feet
    Year Built: 1986
    Short Sale
View Details
1 of 3 Street view of Montauk Hwy East Moriches, NY 11940 REO Foreclosure home
    Montauk Hwy
    East Moriches, NY 11940
    4 Beds, 3 Baths
    2,768 Square Feet, Year Built: 2005
    2,768 Square Feet
    Year Built: 2005
    REO Foreclosure
View Details
Hot
1 of 18 Street view of Mastic Blvd Mastic, NY 11950 Short Sale home
    Mastic Blvd
    Mastic, NY 11950
    2 Beds, 1 Bath
    1,482 Square Feet, Year Built: 1988
    1,482 Square Feet
    Year Built: 1988
    Short Sale
View Details
1 of 2 Street view of Claire Ln Sayville, NY 11782 Short Sale home
    Claire Ln
    Sayville, NY 11782
    4 Beds, 2 Baths
    Year Built: 1973
    Year Built: 1973
    Short Sale
View Details
Hot
1 of 25 Street view of Swan Lake Dr Patchogue, NY 11772 Short Sale home
    Swan Lake Dr
    Patchogue, NY 11772
    3 Beds, 2 Baths
    2,231 Square Feet, Year Built: 1959
    2,231 Square Feet
    Year Built: 1959
    Short Sale
View Details
Exploring the rent-to-own real estate market in Fire Island, NY is a great alternative housing option. Whether you have bad credit and need time to repair your scores or simply can't afford a large down payment on a traditional home sale, renting to own allows you to rebuild your credit, save money, and build equity all while living in the home you'll eventually own. If you find a house you love, register with RentToOwn.org so you can gain full access to all price, property, and contact information! We look forward to helping you realize your home ownership dreams with Fire Island, NY rent-to-own houses.